Missional Business - is that impossible?
Work has been on my mind a lot recently, both with what it means and is about and also with what’s happening day to day. I’ve been writing about theology but am reminded that “theology” is not such a great word for some (can I have a better word please?). I find myself caught in an interesting place - other bloggers I respect have a passion for organic, creative and dynamic missional relationship type living and object (rightly) to the “corporatisation” of the church. So does that I mean I have to have a disconnect between my life in business and my life outside of work - clearly not! And yet look at the language that is acceptable in each zone:
Work
- focus, purpose, authority, structure, measurement, accountability, process
Non Work
- creative, intentional, dynamic, inspirational, missional, community, relational,
I’m not arguing for the work culture to take over the church. Neither am I arguing that the work words are wrong, many of them bring a lot of helpful aspects to daily living. However, my heart longs for a job that includes the non work words too. I want to have an integrated life, not a sacred/secular split. However, I find that in Scotland, often it is not only that the sacred can’t be spoken to in a work context, it’s also that the secular can’t be spoken to in a non work context.
I have read a lot of missional living in the last year (Mak’s missional manifesto I thought was very helpful) and also about chasing lions and occasionally hear of volunteering roles for “web strategy” and think about green grass and other sides. I watch as others see that quitting is the way of chasing the lion in their own situation.
The challenge for me is how to bring it all together. I don’t believe that I should be working full time for a Christian organisation (unless it’s that web strategy job lol) - I can’t see how this would fit with the experience I’ve had in business to date, which surely must have had a purpose other than financing giving? (Plus also, I like my 5 days a week of work, rather than 6 - why is it we get our pastors and staff to work 52 days more a year than we ask of ourselves? Do they get paid proportionately for that?) I also can’t see how the current job allows for working issues of justice and community and restoration into it (but if you can, let me know!)
And I wonder if the way to bring it together is through companies like this, or this. So my ramblings below on “theology of business” is just me trying to work through what a restored business environment would look like. How can business be a force for good? Surely it must be more than having a token corporate and social responsibility programme?
I’m working in my mind of a 3 stage business:
Stage 1 - a series of local, community based, relational businesses with Jesus values
Stage 2 - taking the cashflow from stage 1 into a fund, and investing that into microfinance etc until the cash is needed for stage 3
Stage 3 - funding people to live missionally in the poorer neighbourhoods, and to facilitate the restoration of people who are suffering.
It’s no excuse to do this from a distance, so it would involve commitment, and engagement with people. Relationships would be formed all the way through.
I call this a “zero profit” corporation, as it gives all its profits away to stage 3. It’s not a “not for profit”, as it is for profit. But the profits are to serve a higher purpose than just dividends.
Do you too find the sacred/secular split still exists in the language we use?
Can you live missionally completely in the workplace you are in? What challenges do you face?
Duncan,
I quit my job becuase it wasn’t what God made me to do. I’m perusing the passion and giftedness I have and seeking to use that where it’s most needed.
Simply put:
1. What are you most gifted at doing?
2. What do you have passion for?
3. Where is there a need?
Where those three intersect I see a “sweet spot” for God’s calling.
Billy, thanks - I hope you didn’t think I was criticising, I think, as I hope my comment on your blog made clear, that you are going with the gifting, which is pretty exciting.
We worked through a few of the issues that you raise above when our small group studied the Network course:
My answers:
and execution (i.e. getting things done)
1. Strategy & Planning, Writing, Ideas, Reading, Using the Net
2. Business being used to provide people with jobs and dignity, money being used to free people from financial slavery, people being freed up to experience the options that life holds for them, people making the most of opportunities given to them, the USA (!!), church being all it can be, Jesus being praised, and driving out inefficiencies.
3. Edinburgh. The world.
Thanks Billy, you kind of just affirmed my thought pattern, perhaps without meaning to.
I’m not very business-savvy, but I think this is a great idea. If Christ-like values were inherrent to business practices (much less the infrastructure), there would be a lot of community transformation going on.
And as far as the question of whether “business” is ok for the church, I think you have a great understanding. A book I am wanting to read is “Brothers, we are not professionals” by John Piper, which seems to address this issue (but again, I haven’t read it).
That said, there are many with “Kingly” sets of gifts, as outlined in scripture like the “executives” Nehemiah or David. God has gifted you and others with a talent and understanding for that sort of thing. Should a church adopt it to the exclusion of the prophet or priestly giftings? No. But as with all things, there is an appropriate time and place for gifts to be practiced…
… ESPECIALLY when they edify the body and others to the degree that you are talking about (I Cor. 14 ).
I love your idea. Let me know how it goes!
Brad, thanks - I’m intrigued. Can you expand on the Nehemiah reference and what exactly you meant? I’m not sure what you mean by “Kingly gift”?
Re Piper, I tried one and it was tough, it’s still on the shelf. But then I’m “only” a businessman…..
Good to have your thoughts.
Duncan,
“
No, I didn’t thin you were criticizing. Just adding to the discussion.
Tone of voice does get lost sometimes.
I need to use more of these ”
Duncan,
In Re: to Nehemiah…
There is a growing trend to recognize spiritual gifting in terms of the offices of Christ (prophet, priest, and king), where each category has various spiritual gifts to be considered “kingly” or “priestly” (Driscoll is one of them, actually).
Nehemiah, for example, is very much a “king” (leadership, administration, exhortation) with probably some “prophet” (teaching, wisdom). Yet he was also very aware of his role as a “kingly” servant of God. This is illustrated when it is Ezra, not Nehemiah, who teaches the scriptures and dedicates the new Temple. One would think (by our cultural standards, anyway), that the guy who worked so hard, who led the rebuilding of the walls and the temple, would be the one to read the scriptures aloud for the first time, but he knew he was not that role.
In the same way, as image bearers of God, we too have roles in accordance with our giftedness. You certainly strike me as someone with a “kingly” set of gifts. If you are good at business, praise God! We are certainly in need of people like you! If you can find a way to use your gifts to build up or edify the body of Christ, and show His love to ALL people, how is that not from God?
Good stuff, bro. Sorry that was long, I hope I answered your question(s).
Brad, thanks, really helpful. I guess I’d never heard the giftings decribed in that way, which was what threw me. Every day is a school day for me…….
This is exciting!
You are what Tom Wolfe, in the book titled Bonfire of the Vanities, describes as a Master of the Universe. This kind of study and investigation carries much more weight, at least with me, than if Karlos or Jezza came to the same conclusion. I look forward to reading/hearing your thoughts.
I’m guessing your point of departure in the post-modern era will have to start with defining things.
What is work? For God? For Man?
What is business?
What is profit?
What is fair?
A helpful resource might be a book by Wayne Grudem who takes a look at business. He talks about the inherent goodness of work and business. He tackles issues like competition, sales, employment, capital etc etc.
M8, I’m still reading Total Truth, give me some time…….